Hulu wasted zero time hitting the “renew” button on All’s Fair, handing the legal drama a second season just weeks after its debut. Critics may not have been swooning, but viewers clearly showed up—and in the streaming era, eyeballs beat think-pieces every single time. All’s Fair pulled in the kind of day-one curiosity that made Hulu execs say, “Yeah… run that back.”
Why All’s Fair Renewed Announcement Wasn’t Totally Unexpected
The renewal may seem surprising if you only look through critic reviews because many of them were blunt about the show’s uneven tone and dramatic swings. But the audience numbers tell a different story.
Hulu revealed that All’s Fair delivered its biggest scripted series launch in three years, attracting more than three million global viewers within its opening days. For a platform competing with dozens of new releases every month, that kind of early traction is impossible to ignore.
The series comes from Ryan Murphy, a creator whose name along draws crowds, and the cast only amplified the attention. Kim Kardashian stars alongside Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, and Teyana Taylor. With that lineup, even skeptics tuned in to see how those personalities would share the screen. Curiosity played a huge role in the initial surge, but the sheer volume of viewers is what pushed the renewal forward.
A Show with Plenty of Buzz and Its Fair Share of Flaws
All’s Fair follows a group of female divorce attorneys who leave their Los Angeles firm to start their own practice. The premises give the show built-in drama: high-profile clients, messy breakups, office politics, and the personal baggage each character brings along. It’s the kind of environment where tension and conflict are constant, making it part of the show’s appeal.
Still, critics didn’t hold back. Many pointed out that the show occasionally traded character development for spectacles. Others felt the tone jumped around too much, making it hard to tell whether the series wanted to be a high-gloss soap opera, a grounded legal drama, or something in between. But even viewers who agreed with some of the criticism kept watching. The conversation online was active, which is exactly the kind of energy a streaming platform likes to see in a new show.
That’s why the All’s Fair renewed season 2 makes more sense the longer you look at the situation. The show was never meant to be a quiet release. It was designed to be a buzzy title with a large ensemble and plenty of talking points. Hulu measured success accordingly.
Season 2 Has Time to Smooth Out the Rough Spots
With production expected to begin in spring 2026, the creative team now has room to recalibrate before filming starts. Season 1 wraps on December 23, leaving another month for the writers to sift through what worked and what needs work. Early notes from viewers suggest the show would benefit from slowing down and giving the characters more emotional space. The cast is full of heavy hitters, and leaning into character-driven storytelling could elevate the next season.
There’s been no official cast announcement for All’s Fair renewed season 2, but the core ensemble is expected to return. Their chemistry is one of the show’s strongest elements, and the second season could build on those dynamics.
A Second Season with Potential for Success
While the first season’s reception was far from perfect, All’s Fair renewed season 2 gives the series another chance to learn and grow. Season 2 can refine the tone, deepen the characters, and build on the foundation that attracted audiences. The decision to bring the show back isn’t about what All’s Fair was in its debut. It’s about what it could become with another season to find its footing.