“Poker Face” Season 2 Promises Even Bigger Twists—And a Cast You Won’t Believe
Get ready—”Poker Face” is rolling back into town on May 8, and Charlie Cale is once again in the driver’s seat (literally and figuratively).
After a critically acclaimed first season, the lie-detecting drifter played by Natasha Lyonne returns for another batch of strange, hilarious, and sometimes downright bizarre murder cases. If you loved the show’s mix of mystery, deadpan humor, and nostalgic crime-of-the-week structure, Season 2 is about to give you even more.
At the end of Season 1, Charlie left behind a trail of solved crimes and enemies, and now she’s back on the road—still dodging trouble and drawn into it at every turn. Each episode sees her in a new place, stumbling across a murder and, of course, uncovering the truth through her uncanny ability to tell when someone’s lying. Her only constant companion? Her beat-up Plymouth Barracuda, now practically a character in its own right.
From offbeat funeral homes to alligator farms, talent shows, and shady baseball games, Charlie’s journey continues through small-town America, where nothing is ever quite what it seems.
“Poker Face”: A Killer Cast of Guest Stars
“Poker Face” is known for its impressive lineup of guest stars, and Season 2 takes it to the next level. The new season will feature appearances from:
- Cynthia Erivo
- Giancarlo Esposito
- Awkwafina
- Kumail Nanjiani
- Justin Theroux
- Melanie Lynskey
- Katie Holmes
- Rhea Perlman (back from Season 1)
- Each episode introduces a whole new cast of characters—and suspects—giving these big-name stars a chance to shine in roles that are quirky, dark, funny, or all three.
“Poker Face”: Same Style, Fresh Direction
While Rian Johnson (creator of “Knives Out”) remains a driving force behind the series, Season 2 brings on Tony Tost (“Longmire”, “The Terror”) as showrunner. It’s a change that promises to bring some fresh perspective while staying true to what fans love: a stylish, character-driven mystery format with a modern edge. Lyonne also returns not just as the star, but as a writer and director, continuing to help shape the voice of the show.
Each episode of “Poker Face” still stands on its own, which means you can hop in at any time without getting lost—but longtime fans will catch character arcs and ongoing storylines weaving subtly through the season. The creators have teased that this season will lean even further into the weird and wonderful, with settings and scenarios that push the limits of what Charlie can solve—and what she’s willing to confront.
The Season 2 trailer dropped to lots of fanfare, showing snippets of intense standoffs, hilariously awkward encounters, and Charlie doing what she does best—calling out liars with a raised eyebrow and a sharp one-liner. Fans are already theorizing about what connections might pop up between seasons and which guest stars will steal the show.
If Season 1 was a love letter to classic detective shows, Season 2 of “Poker Face” is doubling down with bigger mysteries, weirder cases, and even more charm. With Natasha Lyonne at the heart of it all, Poker Face continues to prove that solving murders can be just as funny as it is thrilling.
Mark your calendars for May 8—this season is one ride you won’t want to miss.
More On:TV